Re: American Idol
Posted 3/1/2007 12:58:48 AM by NS1976

OK heres my 2 cents...

I do this every year...LOL

Going home...

Antonella...absolutely horrible. She does not deserve to be there AT ALL!

Alaina..she was better than last week but still not good enough. Wouldnt mind seeing her leave.


Leslie..also think she was better than last week but I find her kind of weird and I dont think she will make top 12.


Lakisha...LOVE her voice..she is amazing..but her personality is a little off for me. I am not sure if shes shy and very nervous but it looks like she doesnt want to be there.

Melinda...
Sabrina..I thought she was better last week but she is one of my favorites.

Gina..I dont think she deserves to be in top 12. She reminds me of Amy Adams from years ago but I liked Amy much better.

Jordin...Better last week but overall pretty good..shes young so she has time to get better.

Haley..I thought she was way better than last week. I think she may stay just because she is the prettiest of the group. I think she is beautiful!

Stephanie...Shes good but a little non-descript. Has a good voice though.

Melinda..I think she is going to take it this year if she stays this good. Her performance tonight had me in tears, she was excellent. She just needs to get over her nerves...she seems so stiff.
Print Post      Close Window