Re: New Orleans Mayor Transcript to Feds: "Get off your asses"
Posted 9/3/2005 12:49:08 AM by Eva Luna


Posted by Leeners


Posted by MrsProfessor
...it was just a matter of time before 9/11 or something equally horrific happened.



"A matter of time before something happened" and "expecting the 9/11 attacks" are two different things. Completely different things.

Sasha, my apologies for the fervor of my post. I know it was written as directed at you but it truly was meant to be a statement against this way of thinking as a whole.

It angers me beyond belief that people would insinuate that anyone had any concept of the September 11th attacks and what they were and just let it happen. There were missed cues and missteps by all branches of government, across two administrations - there has been, and continues to be, no doubt about that. However, the way it has been stated and written throughout this post by numerous people is the "expectation" and "knowledge" that it was going to happen. Call it hubris, call it ignorance - call it whatever you like - but you would have been hard pressed, I can almost guarantee, to have found a single person in this country, government official or otherwise, that could have believed anything resembling what happened on September 11th could have happened here on American soil. There were numerous plots thwarted between 1993 and 2001, some public and some not-so-public. Do you all really have so little faith in humanity, really have the belief that those elected to government, would actually know something like this was going to happen - not that it could, that was going to happen - and they didn't care? Some people may say it's a matter of semantics but I think that words, at this point, are the most important thing we have. To twist those and say we "knew" and "expected" these attacks... it's irresponsible and completely incomprehensible.

Sasha, I completely agree with you that the government is run like a business. The difference is, I 100% believe it should be. Maybe it's cold-hearted to some but it is a reality - it's nice to have a social cause but when it comes to running a country of almost 300 million people, there is no other way to operate.

So to whoever I offended, I apologize. This particular topic, the insinuation that our leaders essentially didn't give a rat's as$ if thousands of people lived or died, if our country came under foreign attack, if we were displayed as 'touchable' to the outside world - that's just unacceptable to me and I will defend my view to the end.



Sorry, I just woke up from my nap as it seems that I now have a fever and a sore throat to nurse. But I'll be OK...

Back to this, thanks MrsProfessor for your comments...although I have thick skin and don't get offended by comments that easily, especially when someone is defending their POV, I appreciate it! Chat Icon

Eileen, I'll say it again and I'll say it for the last time. Yes, I believe the government had "expectation" and "knowledge" that it was going to happen." I'm not and was not pointing blame at any particular administration. Although I strongly dislike our current President, I think he's merely a puppet and definitely just the "face" behind the administration...so it goes much deeper than him. Clues and bonds go back to the 80's so to blame it on Bush who was still "wet behind the ears" when September 11th happened would be unfair. But I do believe that his administration did nothing to distinguish facts from fiction and had Iraq on the brain regardless of any attacks on us. Osama Bin Laden gave them an excuse. They took that opportunity and turned it into something else. The terrorist threat is still very much present, regardless of the "colors" or the "alerts". As I write this there are people plotting against us, children learning to hate us, men and women vowing to destroy us. We're always a target, that's pretty much known...and there were a lot of rumblings before the attacks - maybe, just maybe believing we're not "invincible" and actually listening to the clues could have helped...just a little bit. Again, I don't think anyone expected the devastation to be as severe and that's probably why it was brushed off. I do hope they learned their lesson and history will not repeat itself. To quote you: "To twist those and say we "knew" and "expected" these attacks... it's irresponsible and completely incomprehensible." - that may be your belief, but I think otherwise. We're not as strong as the government would like us to think we are. Since the bombings in London occurred I have been wondering how come they managed to arrest and get so much information...even possibly thwart attacks, but we can't? What's the interest in the Middle East and non-democratic governments? We have people right here in the US planning attacks. All of the 9/11 terrorists were living here. Yes, they came from abroad. But we gave them their knowledge. How about focusing a little - or a lot - of our resources internally?

Again, quoting you "Sasha, I completely agree with you that the government is run like a business. The difference is, I 100% believe it should be. Maybe it's cold-hearted to some but it is a reality - it's nice to have a social cause but when it comes to running a country of almost 300 million people, there is no other way to operate." - yes, the government should be run like a business. But this particular "corporation" is not doing anything for its "employees". There are nameless social issues that are currently not being addressed since we seem so pre-occupied with foreign policy. One of them was splattered all over the news because of Katrina...poverty is rampant...as is evident in N.O. where most of the population is well below the national poverty level. There's drugs, national terrorism, overpopulated jail cells, unemployment, teenage pregnancy...really too many to list. And our eaders could really give a rats a$s if thousands of people died...I'll bring up one point and I'll probably get heat for this. But our young men and women going to war, many of them from the South, from the very areas affected by Katrina - so poor that they have no choice but to volunteer, a great majority of them are not healthy enough to enlist. There's asthma, birth defects, heart issues - yet rules are bent and they're sent into harm's way...essentially to die. Many of them don't even make it onto the war zone - boot camp and the rigorous exercises will be as far as they get. But that's a "sacrifice", I guess and the ends (which I have yet to understand Chat Icon) justifies the means Chat Icon.
I realize that most of us are sheltered and I thank God we have the freedom to sit and write this, to eat, to express how we feel. But I grew up poor...really, really poor. I came from the only commonwealth still in existence. A place where the majority of the population, my father included, is active in some branch of the military. My grandfather is a Korean War veteran. My dad is a Gulf War and Operation Iraqi Freedom veteran (although luckily he never had to serve on the ground, he stood behind and was sent to training camps inside the US). But he has been to Panama, to Guatemala and other S. American countries and helped build hospitals, heal the sick (he's an RN) and has seen devastation firsthand. He's been involved in some sort of military since before I was born and it is his life. The reserves, the National Guard, the Army. A lot of their enrollees are from Puerto Rico. When war, chaos or tragedy occurs and they "call in the troops" the very first place to be called is PR. Where you aware of this? We're essentially still being used as "guinea pigs" sent in first, on the ground first. But this is instilled and taught to kids from a very early age...most do it with pride...hoping this is their "way out". The government chooses to be a commonwealth knowing that it needs the aid it has relied on for so long. So our beaches have grenades and are boobie trapped. So our ocean has sunken submarines and torpedoes. So what? Chat Icon That's an entire different discussion though and one I won't get into here or now.
I will continue to believe that this current government does not truly care about its people. The bottom line (is the oil OK, BTW? Chat Icon) comes first...I do thank the heavens that humanity is stepping in. That there are simple, normal human beings doing more for these homeless and sick people affected by Katrina...and much quicker...than our government. Why did it take Bush 4 days to go down there? Where was the Secretary of State? Where is the Vice President? Where is the quick action that we demonstrate toward others? Oh, I think I know...because there is nothing for us to gain by getting involved there's no rush. This is in our backyard...we'll get to it eventually. Too bad people are dying by the minute.
Print Post      Close Window