Re: Need your honest opinions SORRY LONG
Posted 2/7/2007 8:00:51 AM by MsMBV

My ILs are pushing for this too, and I am personally against it. I (and this is my personal opinion from the experiences in my own family, so please no one take offense) feel that it is a little unfair for any child to have to "share" their name with someone. To me it almost pre-defines their personality and their importance in the family. I know with DH, he was named after someone & BIL was not. There is a fierce difference in the way they are percieved within the family, and it affects both of them. For the past 32 years DH is reminded at every family function about how he was named after blah blah, and he was a great man, and etc. They never fail to say to BIL, "I have no idea where your mother got your name from." Yeah, way to make a kid feel good.Chat Icon


I also think that whatever you decide to name your child should come from what you & DH feel in your heart. If naming the baby after someone is not 100% what you want, then I think you should not have to do it. It is YOUR baby, after all.

I know this is a tough issue. Good LuckChat Icon

ETA: As a compromise we are using the first initial "G" for our names, since it is the initial of all of our Grandparents as well as DHs name in italian.
Print Post      Close Window