Re: top chef
Posted 1/25/2007 4:19:11 PM by Blazesyth


Posted by nixy


Posted by Blazesyth

I think the problem with this show (along with Project Runway) is that the contestants seem to be judged ONLY on what they are presenting at that time. I think they should be judged for what they make that week, yes but for elimination they should take into account the contestants previous work also.

Sam had SO MANY MORE dishes that were superior to Ilan's, but just because Ilan took more of a risk this week than Sam did, he's still in it.




they actually said that sam had won the most quickfire challenges, but Ilan had won the most Elimination challenges.

I was surprised by that.




Really? I dont know, personally Sam's food looks more appetizing to me, he had a fuller range. It seems that Ilan will only make the type of food he makes in his restaurant.


Print Post      Close Window