Re: what is the difference between the
Posted 1/24/2007 9:07:24 PM by SuzyQ

I need to get one too and I just read the following on Baby Bargains website:

Humidifiers

Even if you don’t live in a dry climate, you might consider a humidifier for baby’s room during the winter months. Why? Forced-air heat or air conditioning can dry out a house quickly. When it comes to humidifiers, you have two choices:

u Cool mist. These models work either by evaporation (a filter traps minerals and impurities and then a fan sends the cool mist into the air) or ultrasonic (which uses an electronic transducer to create cool mist). Some folks like ultrasonic models since they are quieter; on the other hand, the fan in evaporative humidifiers generates white noise that can comfort a fussy baby.

u Warm mist. These humidifiers have a heating system to release warm mist into the air. Some warm mist humidifiers have a “vaporizer” feature that allows you to vaporize prescribed medicine into the baby’s room (although doctors rarely prescribe that today). These models make a bit of noise when they heat up the water (usually, it’s a gurgling sound), but they are quieter than cool mist evaporative models with fans.

So, should you get a warm or cool mist model? It’s a toss-up. Warm mist models can raise the temperature in baby’s room—that could be a plus (if your house is somewhat drafty) or a minus (if baby’s room gets too warm). Each model requires regular cleaning every week and replacement of filters every four to eight weeks.

The disadvantages of humidifiers: evaporative coolers have filters that trap mineral deposits. Over time deposits can reduce the effectiveness of the wick. For ultrasonic humidifiers, mineral deposits can be dispersed through the air as “white dust” which is a cleaning hassle (and some believe a health hazard.) Yes, you can use distilled water in ultrasonic humidifiers, but that’s expensive. Finally, what about warm mist humidifiers? Some doctors don’t recommend these because they believe a warm, moist environment can lead to bacteria growth.

One feature we recommend: a built-in humidistat. This feature works much the same way a thermostat controls your heat or air conditioning. When the humidity in a room reaches a preset level, the humidistat shuts off the humidifier. If the humidity drops, the unit turns back on. Some cheaper humidifiers lack humidistats; we suggest skipping those models.

What are the best brands? We like the Holmes brand (800-5-HOLMES; www.holmesproducts.com) as well as models by Duracraft/Honeywell. Holmes makes both warm and cool mist models as well as ultrasonic units. They’re sold at reasonable prices at discounters like Wal-Mart and Target (among many other stores).

One reader, Valerie Graham, recommended the Slant/Fin ultra-violet warm mist germ-free humidifier. “We live in a rural, arid mountainous environment and I suffer from many allergies. I purchased one for the nursery and found it at Babies R Us for $79. I did a lot of research, and this humidifier has a dual germicidal process—both ultraviolet light and boiling (vaporization). There is no white dust. There are no replacement filters, wicks, or cartridges. It operates very quietly. I have seen it in other catalogs—Brookstone, Hard to Find Tools, Harmony—for over $100. It kills 99.9% of bacteria and molds and spores. I think it is a wonderful product.”

What about humidifiers by juvenile product makers? We find them to be overpriced and underpowered. For example, Evenflo sells both warm and cool-mist 2.5-gallon models for $40 at Babies R Us. That’s nice, but we’ve seen the same size humidifiers at discounters for $30 or less. Another benefit for Holmes: all their humidifiers are treated with “Microban” antibacterial protection in the plastic (and in the cool mist wick filters).

A buying note: we suggest buying a humidifier from a store with a good return policy. Like any electronic device, you may have to return a defective one if you find it doesn’t work properly. One reader who bought a humidifier online direct from the manufacturer found this out the hard way—she discovered the manufacturer wouldn’t take back the defective model, even though it was just a week old!

What’s the right size humidifier? For most standard size bedrooms, a 1.5 to 2.0-gallon humidifier should do. For larger rooms, check out these guidelines:



Area Humidified Room Size Needed Output

(in sq. ft.) (gallons per day)

500 or lower Very Small 1.5 to 2.0

530-600 Small to Medium 2.2 to 2.5

700-800 Medium 3.0 to 3.5

900-1000 Medium to Large 4.0 to 5.0

1000-2000 Large to Whole House 7.0 to 9.0

Over 2000 Whole house 10.0 or higher

Source: www.holmesproducts.com





Print Post      Close Window