|
Re: Shouldnt I choose the form of discipline?
Posted 11/24/2006 11:07:44 AM by 05mommy09
See thats my whole thing- I was sitting right there- my son was on my lap- if I thought or felt he needed to be disciplined (which Im sorry at this age- other than saying no- and removing the object- I dont think there should be any form of discipline) then I wouldve done so- Who the heck are you to take matters into your own hands??? I did write my MIL and email re: this incident- since trying to talk to her just consists of her yelling and making a war... This is what I wrote: ( edited to hide names) I was totally on the fence about bringing this up- but since its bothering me and Ryan and I discussed it, I thought maybe it would be best- to at least put my mind at ease... Yesterday while RJ kept throwing his cup on the floor- FIL came over and tapped Ryan on the hand- I was in complete shock for, that is the last person Id ever think that would do that... It didnt hurt him- I think he kinda looked like "what the heck was that" but it still made me a little uncomfortable. I KNOW you guys would never ever hurt him (and again this was more of a "love tap") but noneless its not how DH and I have choosen to discipline our child... I feel it will only teach RJ that this is ok to do to other adults and or children, and its not... When he is a little older we may change our view on this... but right now its not the route we want to take,,, Please reassure me that you guys have never handled a situation like this before... and Please dont get all huffy about this....Im not accusing, or making this a war- I was sitting right there- holding RJ when this happend- and couldnt believe my own eyes- but rather than "saying something in the situation" (the way your son assures me I should have) I thought I would just ask you to please refrain from this kind of discipline... And please know- had it been anyone else- I prob. would have said something right then and there- but becasue I KNOW his attentions werent to "hit" him, and you guys would NEVER EVER do anything to hurt my child, I didnt... (this is simply more because I just dont want to teach him the wrong thing, and since you take care of RJ we need to be on the same page.) Thanks Her reply in a bold lettering might I add was this: I will let FIL read your e-mail. And to 'reasure you', and 'put your mind at ease', the answer is No..we have never handled a situation like that before and I am sure the both of you know that we would never Hit, Scream, Hurt or Discipline our grandchild in a way that is unsafe or teaches him to do anything wrong. I'm glad you mentioned this. Not exactly sure how im supposed to take this- is she callling me a liar? Is she denying this incident? The bold lettering and the quotes on my words..smells like sarcasam to me |