Re: Shouldnt I choose the form of discipline?
Posted 11/24/2006 7:32:07 AM by MomofMandB

My mother always disciplined us by smacking us (not hard, mind you, but hard enough to "teach us a lesson.") My sister also believes in a "soft" smack on the tush for bad behavior. Her children are older than mine, and she is fine with my mom giving them a soft smack. Well, once when my son was about 3 he was fresh to my mother, and she smacked him. My mom is truly my best friend, so I had a VERY hard time speaking to her about this, but I explained that we don NOT hit Max for any reason. If she is frustrated by that, we will give her some suggestions for discipline. She was NOT pleased at first (of course, thinking she knows better), but has learned that he is OUR son, and WE make the decisions. She hasn't hit him again since, and now she has other strategies that work (more effectively).

I think you need to have DH talk to your FIL, since he is his son, and explain that neither of you believe in hitting in any way for any reason. Offer to give him alternatives that you think are acceptable, so he doesn't feel powerless when your DS misbehaves.

Good luck, this is a very difficult situation!
Print Post      Close Window