Re: "to hell and back?"
Posted 10/11/2006 1:09:50 PM by Eva Luna


Posted by nov04libride


Posted by JenniferEver

So you're saying for a relative, you'd do whatever ti takes, but for a friend, you'd draw the line sooner...

What if someone, through a mental illness, or maybe not, as an outside person, you don't know, just did something horrible to you, but they're a relative...(I'm thinking ofmy dad in this case), but you believe it's a mental illness, do you ever say "Well that person is so effed up, I don't ever want to deal with them again" or is it always "I will try to help this person" whether they want the help or not?

This is not really a specific question, but more of a hypothetical and a where do you draw the line, and how do you know what is the illness, and what the person willingly being mean, or being lazy



Someone with a mental illness is much like an alcoholic--you cannot force them to get help. Now my father was very unkind to my mother before they got divorced, but I will never cut him out of my life. I don't agree with all of the things he did, but he is my father, and if he ever needed help I would be there.

In terms of whether it is mental illness, I think only someone very close to the person can determine whether the change in behavior is a natural change due to reasonable causes (a death in the family, etc.), or mental illness. Someone who lies on the couch every day not making an effort to go to work or get dressed may be suffering from depression, or may be a lazy bum. Only people who know him will know if that is his real personality.



Again, I agree...and it's much easier than typing similar thoughts.

I would never cut off family. My immediate family has been far from perfect...but I've stuck by it.

A lot comes from maturity though, and understanding people's limitations.
Print Post      Close Window