|
Re: Mental Illness Spinoff
Posted 7/27/2005 10:43:32 AM by JenniferEver I think there are a lot of factors. We have underdiagnosis in some areas and overdiagnosis in others. First of all I think we knowa lot more about mentla illness than we did 20 years ago. There's no (or little) stigma against going to a therapist or a psychiatrist. We have all of these shows like Dr. Phil where everyone now knows these words "bi-polar", "ADHD", "Clinical Depression", "OCD" and has some idea of what ithey mean, so people are more likely to see symptoms in themselves or a loved one and seek help. Also it's not as scary now to b diagnosed with a disorder. People don't need to worry about being put away, called hysterical, put on Electro Shock therapy, or have to face the side effects and dangers of MAOI drugs. The SSRIs that people are given for depression, anxiety, OCD, etc are so much safer and have so many fewer side effects (though I think they're a lot more dangerous than people are led to believe but that's another story). I think it's good that more people are being diagnosed because they cna get the treatment they need. On the other hand there's a lot of overdiagnosis and self-diagnosis. The overdiagnosis is especially prevalent with ADHD. Parents have unruly kids and just assume it's ADHD. The school wants to get every kid on ritalin so they don't have to deal with it. But the truth is a LOT of these parents just ave spoiled brat kids who act that way not because they can't control it, but because they don't know how to behave. It's like the ADHD diagnosis is an excuse to absolve people of bad parenting. Then, you know, "It's not my fault my kid is punching your kid. he has ADHD." It doens't work that way. Hopefully as more people become educated about these diseases we'll get a lot more accurate diagnoses and cut down on the erroneous ones. Another thing is that a lot of doctors will diagnose an illness based on a drug. When I was first going to doctors for ADD, the first doctor I went to gave me ritalin and told me that if it works I have ADD, if it doens't, I don't (needless to say I left that doctor). This works out well for the doctors, because they are given huge incentives to prescribe these drugs, but it's not good for the patients who ar eebing uneccesarily drugged or given the wrong medication. I think this happens alot. I see it all the time. It's unbelievable how quick even an internist is to hand over a prescription for a tranquilizer, a stimulant or an SSRI. it's like amoxicillin. It's ridiculous. I just hope that as everyone is more educatied, patients, doctors, and family members of pateints, we'll be able to hone in on getting people ana ccurate diagnosis and the correct treatment. |