Re: Is this considered rude...
Posted 9/11/2006 2:22:56 PM by preciouslove
Posted by anna
I would ABSOLUTELY NOTTTTT give them money. How can someone ASK for money "for this reason" and the reason NOT being "what she wants for Christmas" ???????????? especially when the kids ARE old enough to express their wishes. But thats not even the case, they should let everyone do what they choose, and I know you being VERY thoughtful with your gifts, why would anyone take that away from you? (the fun and thought you put into gifts?) does that make sense? and its not WHAT the gift is, its the thought behind it !
I would reply back with "Actually we did early shopping online this year" and that you bought their gifts already. DONE. period. Im NOT a rule follower especially in situations like this.
Actually makes them look quite pathetic, so "all they have" is really just debt and they must be living way above their means huh ? so much for thinking theyre high and above others
and im sure if you did something like this, youd get a comment months down the road "So is this the furniture WE BOUGHT?" or something sarcastic..
you guys are too good for your own good. do what you choose but I would not "Follow their rules".
No way. I guess it also depends how close you are to someone. If I did that with my siblings, we'd be fine with it, but its not done with the background info you have stated about the situation and in some cases, someone might get a gift on sale, so do they want the sale price or the retail value ??
ETA: Sorry you got me rambling. didnt they do this last year too ?? grrrrr.
Girl I couldn't agree more. I told Rob don't give them money, but you know what this is his family let him deal with it. Like I said I would have been fine with it if she would have said something like "the girls have too much clothes and toys can you please give them money or a savings bond".
They ask every year and every year we don't give them money so I don't know why he's giving in this year. God help them if my son gets a cheap gift from them. If we give them money and my son gets a cheap gift from them I'm going to flip my lid, and I won't go nuts on her but on my DH for giving into "their rules"...
I don't mind giving money if it's something the child really wants. You're right Anna that e-mail makes them sound pathetic, even Lisa was saying that the other night. Paul Said he is not giving money. He can't stand Janine.
One year they asked for money so they could buy a table and chairs set for the girls for the backyard...what the F***!!!!!!!
|