Re: Vaccine Misconceptions?
Posted 8/27/2021 9:58:24 AM by lululu


Posted by 3girls1dog


Posted by lululu


Posted by ali120206


Posted by GoldenRod

https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vpd/polio/hcp/effectiveness-duration-protection.html


Vaccine Effectiveness
Two doses of inactivated polio vaccine (IPV) are 90% effective or more against polio; three doses are 99% to 100% effective.
...


99% to 100% technically means that there could be breakthrough cases, but so few that we've eliminated the spread.


https://health.mo.gov/living/healthcondiseases/communicable/chickenpox.php


...
Can you get chickenpox if you've been vaccinated?
Yes. About 15% – 20% of people who have received one dose of varicella (chickenpox) vaccine do still get chickenpox if they are exposed, but their disease is usually mild. Vaccinated persons who get chickenpox generally have fewer than 50 spots or bumps, which may resemble bug bites more than typical, fluid-filled chickenpox blisters. In 2006, the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) voted to recommend routine two-dose varicella vaccination for children. In one study, children who received two doses of varicella vaccine were three times less likely to get chickenpox than individuals who have had only one dose.
...



https://www.pennmedicine.org/updates/blogs/health-and-wellness/2019/may/mumps#:~:text=During%20a%20mumps%20outbreak%2C%20people,with%20those%20who%20aren't.


Before vaccination against mumps became widespread in 1967, it was common for Americans to experience the fever, headache, muscle aches, fatigue, puffy cheeks, and swollen jaw caused by this contagious disease.

In the more than 50 years since, though, it’s become much rarer. The MMR vaccine, which protects against measles, mumps, and rubella, is very effective — it lowers your risk of getting the mumps by about 88 percent and has greatly reduced the number of mumps cases in the US.

“However, outbreaks can still occur when people aren’t vaccinated or don’t receive MMR booster shots, as the original immunization can become less effective over time,” explained Karen McGeehan, MD, physician at Penn Family Medicine Chestnut Hill. Since 2006, many US cities – including Philadelphia -- have reported outbreaks of this disease.
...






It’s actually better if you get the chicken pox and not the vaccine - you have better immunity. This is what our ped told us when our 11 month old was covered head to toe in chicken pox… unfortunately it made it difficult to register him for school because the form didn’t print out the vaccine exception for it.



It is not better to get the chicken pox than get the vaccine. The ONLY benefit you will have is better immunity from the chicken pox but getting the chicken pox can also have serious long term side effects while getting the chicken pox vaccine typically does not. Not to mention the chicken pox can be extremely painful and uncomfortable, especially if you get it as an older child, young adult or adult. It is almost never better to get the disease itself than get the vaccine.

TBH I think the same is probably true of COVID in terms of immunity but I think if the vaccine was as effective as the chicken pox vaccine and was around as long with little to no long term side effects, you would be crazy to prefer getting COVID to getting the vaccine.



I don't agree. My older daughter got the chicken pox. there was no vaccine back then. Most kids during her childhood got chickenpox as did my generation not sure about any long term effects and with her it was not a traumatic experience. By my next kid there was a vaccine which she got. Now older kid still has immunity other one does not.
I think natural immunity is better.



Natural immunity might be better but just because your experience with chicken pox was mild does not mean that everyone's is. Many people have extreme reactions to chicken pox. My friends sister died from complications related to chicken pox. If you can take a vaccine that is 99.9% effective with little to no side effects vs. getting sick with possible severe side effects the choice is clear. I am sure your younger child can get a booster if her immunity is gone. Many people do not understand that chicken pox, especially if you get it when you are older, can be a very severe disease. It's like Covid, most people will have a mild case and be totally fine but why would you take your chances? Do a little research on chicken pox and you will have a better understanding.
Print Post      Close Window