Re: NY mandates healthcare workers get the vaccine
Posted 8/17/2021 7:15:59 PM by itsbabytime
Posted by MrsG823
Posted by itsbabytime
Posted by MrsG823
Posted by itsbabytime
Posted by MrsG823
Posted by BFNY516
Posted by MrsG823
Posted by Raging2020
Posted by chilltocam
Posted by windyweather21
Posted by chilltocam
There is room for limited religious and medical exceptions in the new mandate
That's great but what about the ones who just don't want it? They will lose many excellent nurses and doctors.
An option of testing should be on the table. Testing should also be for vaccinated also since they can also be sick. It should not be vaccinated or nothing. I actually sent this to my nurse friend who does not plan to get vaccinated but haven't heard back to see what her plans will be.
And there are many many more healthcare workers and patients who do not want to be in close proximity to those who are not vaccinated. What about them? Don't they have a right to a safe work environment? Don't patients have a right to healthcare providers who are much less likely to spread the virus to them? There are many more sides to this than just "many will quit" (or the similar, "many will not frequent a business that requires a vaccine") that you continue to insist is the only valid point of view. NY is not the only State to institute this mandate and I doubt it will be the last. More and more of the US population is getting vaccinated daily. Yes, the pace slowed considerably, but is rising quickly in states that are seeing rising rates of COVID. Eventually, those who refuse for no valid reason, will be left behind - unable to attend many events, restaurants and schools and yes, even their jobs.
But these same people are ok with being in close proximity to a healthcare worker who did not get the flu vaccine during a bad flu season?
Don’t worry many hospitals are also mandating flu shots- I had a choice last year to get a flu shot by 11/1 or find a new job- from what I have heard this year will be the same.
If you’re willing to share, how do you/your colleagues feel about this mandate for the covid vaccine?
On my team of 45 people all but one person willing chose to get vaccinated with in a month of being offered the first shot. The unvaccinated person caught Covid around the time the delta variant was first being discussed. She sobbed that she chose not to get vaccinated after being talked to by multiple people about the risks. We had an overall vaccination rate of nearly 80% of all staff before the mandate. The majority of my colleagues were eager to get vaccinated ASAP. I was initially a bit hesitant (back in December) but after a lot of reading and weighing the odds knowing I was being exposed daily I opted to get vaccinated the first week of January. I think getting the vaccine is another layer of protection against serious illness from Covid. Honestly, most of my colleagues are more worried about long term Covid effects than the initial illness. As physicians and scientists most of my coworkers have the “an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure mentality”. We are used to being required to have our vaccine titers up to date and getting flu shots and boosters for other vaccine if levels are determined to be low are part of the necessary employee health clearance. Medical and religious exceptions are given and a wavier must be signed. I am allergic to a particular “mandatory vaccine” and have a waiver.
Well If your “colleagues” are more worried about long term covid effects then initial illness then they should read the research on the studies that are being done, obviously they are just being started because the first vaccines weren’t given that long ago and no one really knew for sure what would be the impact but studies are coming out now that show even fully vaccinated (I believe it was Pfizer in the study) who had a mild or asymptomatic case of covid are getting long term covid issues - doesn’t seem the vaccine prevents long haul covid issues.
As physicians and scientists (some doing Covid research since March of 2020) we are all very well aware of the current peer reviewed work- FYI in some cases the mRNA vaccines seem to improve long haul Covid symptoms- as I said earlier the vaccine should be used in conjunction with other layers of prevention-like masks and good hand hygiene.
Yes, and so you know what I posted was accurate then, and as for your additional commentary, actually, in some cases ithe vaccine can make the long haul symptoms worse or actually re-ignite or exacerbate symptoms. But, since you seem to know it all and are the expert as a physician and scientist ... I’m sure I don’t need to tell you!
Wow!! No need to attack me. I was in no way minimizing what you said just adding to it. Apparently this is a contest on who is more correct- so much for discussion
I’m sorry, I actually really appreciate the discussion as this is an evolving, novel and very scary situation and I appreciate that there are two sides to the vaccine discussion and neither can honestly say they are 100 percent in the right. I’m sorry if you felt attacked but I hope you understand that just because you work in the medical/research field does not necessarily mean everything you say and your opinion is correct or better than anyone else’s. I think that arrogance about “science” is sometimes misplaced and highly biased by some individuals. I’m a highly educated, very researched person and my opinions are also based on facts and research. I think the best way to have a discussion that we can all learn and grow from is to be respectful and open minded. I’m sorry if I attacked you.
|