Re: Your opinion on infection rate vs death or hospitalization rate
Posted 8/12/2020 10:38:52 AM by seaside


Posted by Pomegranate5


Posted by seaside

Although I have been "called out" in some pretty crude, base ways for, among other things, claiming to be some kind of science expert (??), the truth is that all I have done with respect to decisions that involve analyzing date and various rates is to listen to the voices of experts.

Here is a perfect example of the analysis of one of many such experts with an incredibly informed voice and how he is reading rates and data to protect his family:

https://www.cnn.com/2020/08/12/health/covid-kids-school-gupta-essay/index.html



Great article. He lives in ATLANTA. If I lived in Atlanta I would not be sending my kids to school. I'm sure that goes for many of the parents on this website. But we live on Long Island.

This is a perfect example of what I'm talking about. We can only listen to the "experts" but we pick and choose which experts.



I think I fully agree with you. I don't necessarily think that no one--anywhere in the country--can have any live school. I was answering the question about forming opinions and interpreting data re:death rates, infection rates, etc.

My point was that lay people's feelings and opinions on how to read data are drowning out informed opinions like his when it comes to data analyses and decision making.

I wasn't saying that everyone needed to get to his outcome at all. I think we agree. It is a great article.


Print Post      Close Window