Re: If you need a response when bullied about “overreacting” re: covid
Posted 7/6/2020 10:48:01 AM by SecretlyTTC14


Posted by JennP


Posted by SecretlyTTC14


Posted by JennP

I didn't follow the whole thread so I'm not sure what klingklang has said already but I want to address the cultural aspect of this.

The issue with those anecdotes is that LI is NOT the United States. There are parts of the country, usually rural or semi rural areas but not always, where there is so much rebellion against wearing masks.

31 states STILL do not require them.

Southern states are (for the most part) pushing ahead with reopening despite rapidly rising numbers.

Individualism is very inherent in American culture vs. a more collectivist identity that you see in many other places. Pick yourself up by the bootstraps, I got mine screw everyone else, I only give a shit about myself.

OF COURSE not all Americans are like that. And I think things are (overall) getting better. But in certain areas, among certain groups, that's the dynamic you see and hear.

I think it's worth acknowledging this cultural flaw because we can't make it better if we don't say it out loud.




LI is in the United States. There are plenty of areas in the South that are wearing their masks. Anecdotal evidence from klingklang and her superior friends all over the world is irrelevant. Yes, the USA is an individualistic country, but it is not considered the most individualistic country and Germany is right up there next to the USA in terms of being considered "individualistic".

Americans complain about wearing masks, but a lot of us still wear them. We're allowed to complain about it & we're allowed our opinions. In areas where the government hasn't mandated masks, they don't have to wear them. End of story.

It is your opinion that self-preservation (ie. putting the individual first) is a cultural flaw. Just because you don't like it, doesn't mean it's wrong to be that way. It's actually the opposite of wrong, scientifically it is a basic instinct that we're all born with.



The fact that people don't have to wear masks is "the end of the story" is part of my point. Both the lack of a directive and the "I don't give a shit about other people" sentiment is part of our moral failing as a nation.

Your reference to instinct is irrelevant. We have plenty of instincts that we have to fight to get through the day and function in society. Also, your response fails to account for any nuance. Of course we can and should watch out for ourselves but we also need to consider and watch out for our fellow Americans.

The last word is yours because I am heading out, but I will always not only mourn our failings (i.e. COVID aside, we are the only developed nation that regularly requires people to declare bankruptcy to pay medical bills) but fight to change them.



I don't disagree, especially in regards to healthcare. I'm just saying that if the government in different areas isn't mandating masks, people aren't going to wear them. Maybe that's selfish, but they don't have to. People are going to push back when they think the government is overreaching. I'm glad we live in a country like that. Imagine they could just make new rules that everyone had to live by, with no push back. Yeah, it seems like a no-brainer with masks, but imagine it was something you disagreed with. Imagine Cuomo was a Republican. We're ok with him potentially violating our constitutional rights when it's something we agree with. The problem is, once you allow that, it sets a precedent. Not just for his term, but for the leaders that are elected after him. That is a slippery slope.

In regards to human nature, yes that is a basic explanation that lacks nuance and we do fight other instincts to function in society, but like anything else, if there is no law requiring something, most people will still revert back to self-preservation, where their needs and wants are paramount. It's not a flaw, it's nature. I mean really, people murder other people to take (or defend) what's theirs. They had to make a law saying you can't murder people to deter most people from doing that. If you really don't believe in self-preservation, you would open your home to the homeless, or give all your money and belongings to charity. I'm sure everyone here that is able, donates to causes they care about, but within reason. We don't bankrupt ourselves to give to others. When I say "end-of story", doesn't mean I agree with things the way they are, but that IS how things are and our opinions can't change that.
Print Post      Close Window